Gettin’ Philosophical with Jim Carrey

Last night I was feeling particularly lazy, so I decided to watch a movie on Netflix Instant. Several movies have been in my Instant Queue since I got Netflix in January. The one I chose was Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Just a little behind the times, I know. How could I, a Kate Winslet fan, have never seen this movie from 2004? The answer is Jim Carrey. I just don’t like him very much. Even though I knew this was a dramatic role, I never felt motivated to go out and rent the movie. But now, as it sat on my computer, free for the taking, I wanted to give it a shot. For Kate!

I found that I actually liked Jim Carrey in the movie, instead of liking the movie in spite of him. His physicality translated quite well into the melancholy main character. Give him a shaggy haircut and he becomes a sad puppy dog! There was only one moment when I thought, “Oh no, he’s reverting to Ace Ventura,” but it passed quickly and mercifully. Kate Winslet was wonderful, as usual. Then again, I’m obviously biased in her favor. I loved how her character is (literally) a splash of color against a drab landscape through the movie.

As the IMDB link will tell you, the basic plot is that a couple decides to erase their memories of each other after an ugly breakup. (Bring your tolerance for science-fiction or don’t bother coming.) It reminded me of several films that have come after it: Inception and (500) Days of Summer, one of my favorites in recent years. Inception because the memory-erasing scenes reminded me of the dream sequences. Both processes are complicated enough that a person might be inspired to watch a second time, just trying to figure out exactly what happened. (500) Days of Summer because of the nonlinear storytelling paired with an honest look at the disintegration of a relationship. It’s rather unsettling to see the beginning of a relationship when you know how it will end. The end seems to echo the beginning, at least when constructed by screenwriters.

I appreciate that Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind made me think. The obvious question to viewers is whether they would erase someone from their memory if they could. Right after a breakup, I can imagine that being a very tempting option. The film makes a very good counterpoint, which is that you would have to lose the good memories along with the bad. It seems to me that the best and worst memories often involve the same people because those are the people you care about the most. My first reaction, though, was that you would lose all the lessens learned from that experience. Then wouldn’t you just repeat the same mistakes? I’ll keep the perspective, thanks!



Filed under Movies

7 responses to “Gettin’ Philosophical with Jim Carrey

  1. Mom


    You are wise beyond your years! Must have been all that good parenting. Ha.


  2. Funny, my brother and I just had a similar discussion about Jim Carrey a couple weeks ago. And Eternal Sunshine is the movie that made me love Kate Winslet – about as much as I love your blog, actually. Keep it up!

  3. Melinda

    Not to jump on the “similar discussion” bandwagon but I had one with my roommate this past semester about relationship memory erasure. I think we agreed that in the long-run, it might be better. But then again, the circumstances we were discussing were much different from those in Eternal Sunshine. You bring up an interesting point though, would erasing memories cause you to repeat those mistakes? Would you end up in the same relationship later in life having to learn the same lessons? Maybe I should just rewatch Eternal Sunshine.

    • Yeah, I’m sure there are situations in with memory erasure could be beneficial, particularly if a relationship caused severe psychological damage. But I think for the average breakup, it’s better to remember.

  4. Pingback: Kate Winslet, Have I Loved | Courtney Coherent

  5. Pingback: Best of 2011: Movie Edition, Part 1 | Courtney Coherent

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s